Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

CTyankee

(65,177 posts)
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 12:15 PM Monday

Has anybody here tried to switch to decaf coffee in the morning?

I tried this morning but after the morning news I couldn't stay awake any longer. I was dragging my butt around. Had to go back to bed, woke up after a few hours. Now it's past noon....

End of decaf episode. Going to the food store for more regular coffee.....

45 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Has anybody here tried to switch to decaf coffee in the morning? (Original Post) CTyankee Monday OP
Got a headache The Wizard Monday #1
Oh heavens no... hlthe2b Monday #2
I have high blood pressure and thought I could help keep my bp down by switching to decaf. CTyankee Monday #5
Maybe switch to green or white tea (have the lowest caffeine)... hlthe2b Monday #7
I love the taste of coffee, but the tea you mention look good for an afternoon break... CTyankee Monday #8
Try claudette Monday #3
Will do. I shouldn't shock by old body so badly... CTyankee Monday #6
Yep claudette Monday #13
Decaf is the anti-Christ. CrispyQ Monday #4
Tried to after doc said "no more"... MiHale Monday #9
After a bout of Staph A in my heart valves, i came out of the hospital with 2 prosthetic valves, BobTheSubgenius Monday #10
Caffeine is a vasoconstrictor TexasBushwhacker Tuesday #24
Oh gawd, never! I quit drinking coffee instead. Iggo Monday #11
Not a chance. (nt) Paladin Monday #12
Once... 2naSalit Monday #14
Meh, I've been on decaf for a while now. Wounded Bear Monday #15
I tried it. Different Drummer Monday #16
Message auto-removed Name removed Monday #17
Never! DFW Monday #18
Constant Comment style (orange peel, cinnamon and clove) is pretty good. elleng Tuesday #29
Oh, I used to love constant comment! I wonder if I can find it at my supermarket... CTyankee Tuesday #38
I always bring a few boxes back from the States when I visit. DFW 21 hrs ago #39
Smart, as ever!!! elleng 20 hrs ago #40
Like I said, the small things DFW 20 hrs ago #41
Pretty much all I drink anymore. duncang Tuesday #19
no Skittles Tuesday #20
Oh, heck no. It's either leaded or nothing at all. catbyte Tuesday #21
I can't. I had palpitations like crazy the day after Trump won and I called my doc's office. CTyankee 3 hrs ago #45
No XanaDUer2 Tuesday #22
Decrap coffee? What's the point? bif Tuesday #23
I've never understood the point of decaf coffee JoseBalow Tuesday #25
Coffee FLAVOR! elleng Tuesday #28
Does it elicit some sort of placebo effect? JoseBalow Tuesday #32
I've not noticed placebo effect. elleng Tuesday #33
I feel more awake just smelling coffee brewing JoseBalow Tuesday #34
a truly wonderful smell!!! elleng Tuesday #37
I've gone to 50/50, seems to be ok, not as jittery. Clouds Passing Tuesday #26
I gave up caffeinated MONTHS ago (due to heartburn.) elleng Tuesday #27
Yep! Did it successfully because I piggybacked my cold-turkey withdrawal with a major surgery. I was on so many meds, rainin Tuesday #30
Yes, we did it years ago. No problem... surfered Tuesday #31
Made the switch a few years ago... fairfaxvadem Tuesday #35
I went half decafe/half caffeinated last yr. irisblue Tuesday #36
I had a problem that was exacerbated greatly by caffein, had to switch. lark 14 hrs ago #42
I ONLY drink decaf coffee. milestogo 6 hrs ago #43
I am experimenting with making half decaf and half regular caf. I don't want palpitations from caffeine but frankly I CTyankee 3 hrs ago #44

CTyankee

(65,177 posts)
5. I have high blood pressure and thought I could help keep my bp down by switching to decaf.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 12:23 PM
Monday

Maybe I could try to taper off a bit so my body won't be reactive. But, man, I was wrong...

CTyankee

(65,177 posts)
8. I love the taste of coffee, but the tea you mention look good for an afternoon break...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 12:33 PM
Monday

I could see me taking a break and chilling out with a cup of tea. Sounds nice!

CrispyQ

(38,445 posts)
4. Decaf is the anti-Christ.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 12:22 PM
Monday

LOL. There used to be a coffee mug with that on it.

Enjoy that heavenly cup of real joe!

MiHale

(10,835 posts)
9. Tried to after doc said "no more"...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 12:36 PM
Monday

Blood pressure and a-fib stuff gets in the way of a good espresso, lol. Couldn’t stand it went to half-caf. We buy regular and decaffeinated, then mix to our preferred strength. It was the best way, for us, to cut down on caffeine.

Started out at about a 75/25 mix, by weight, then worked our way down. Now it’s about 25/75 ratio by weight.
Never had to worry about withdraw.

BobTheSubgenius

(11,804 posts)
10. After a bout of Staph A in my heart valves, i came out of the hospital with 2 prosthetic valves,
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 12:38 PM
Monday

During one of the several little lectures we had about various aspects of life going forward, a strict ban on caffeine was conveyed. As I had already detoxed (so to speak), it was easy to do without.

Fast Forward THIRTEEN F-ING YEARS, and I learn that what the lecturer meant but failed to convey was to do without it for the first 6 weeks, then phase it back in. DAMN, was it ever good to get back to real coffee. I once accidentally went cold turkey for 3 days, and an annoyance turned into a raging headache, and my body just KNEW It needed caffeine. After half a cup, my headache was gone. Ben Franklin should have included coffee in his Proof That God Loves Us quote.

TexasBushwhacker

(20,711 posts)
24. Caffeine is a vasoconstrictor
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 05:23 PM
Tuesday

That's why it helps with headaches and why you get rebound headache when you give it up.

You'll also find caffeine in some headache medications and "daytime" flu medicine.

2naSalit

(93,098 posts)
14. Once...
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 02:57 PM
Monday

A long time ago, not worth it.

I did quit coffee for a few years but I became readdicted and I make no apologies for it. If I have to cut back on something, it will be the cream and sugar first.

I make peace with my indulgence by buying ONLY fair trade coffee, period.

Wounded Bear

(60,762 posts)
15. Meh, I've been on decaf for a while now.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:09 PM
Monday

It's all I drink with some rare exceptions.

Of course after all those years of drinking whatever was available, I'm no coffee snob, TBS.

Different Drummer

(8,699 posts)
16. I tried it.
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:11 PM
Monday

Didn't work for me. I have sleep apnea and, without caffeine in the morning, sleepiness overtakes me and I give into it. The naps that resulted prevented me from getting as many things done as I needed and wanted to do.

Response to CTyankee (Original post)

DFW

(56,736 posts)
18. Never!
Mon Dec 9, 2024, 03:56 PM
Monday

I'm a tea drinker. Preferably Russian style (sweetened with marmalade instead of sugar or honey). Some think strawberry marmalade is best, but for me it's apricot. Best case scenario: either Constant Comment style (orange peel, cinnamon and clove) or just cinnamon, and then sweetened with a chunky style apricot marmalade. Morning, noon and night!

Although--one of my favorite funny scenes ever concerned coffee. It was in a crowded hotel breakfast room in Holland, decades ago. A colleague of mine who is from Crete (and looks the part, swarthy skin, tangled dark locks of hair), but grew up in Canada, were having breakfast at a table for four. My friend had been married for fifteen years to a Swedish woman, and they lived in Stockholm for the entire time. His Swedish is pretty much fluent, as is mine. But we speak English when we're together. So, there we were, at the breakfast table for four when an elderly (probably younger than we are now! LOL!!) couple from Sweden was shown to our table. We made room for them, and the woman was immediately complaining about this and that. They had no earthly clue, of course, that we both understood every word they were saying. The service WAS slow, and she grew impatient for her coffee, which never came. Finally, she got up, went over to the coffee pot, and brought it over to pour some coffee for herself and her husband. Being the ever-polite Scandinavian, she asked us--in English--if we would like some coffee as well. My friend said yes, thanks, and I declined. I then told her, in Swedish, that she didn't need to switch to English on our account, I understood Swedish perfectly well. She froze in shock. Then my friend chimed in, also in Swedish, saying, of course we both speak Swedish, and we weren't bothered in the slightest if she wished to continue on her native language. I have no basis for speculation, but I bet they were a LOT more careful from then on about assuming who understood Swedish and who didn't. If two random dark-haired guys with beards speaking English were both fluent in Swedish, who knows who out there might speak it as well?

DFW

(56,736 posts)
39. I always bring a few boxes back from the States when I visit.
Wed Dec 11, 2024, 02:40 AM
21 hrs ago

If I run out, I have more sent. Just one of life’s little pleasures I’d rather not give up if I don’t have to.

DFW

(56,736 posts)
41. Like I said, the small things
Wed Dec 11, 2024, 04:08 AM
20 hrs ago

Not quite like the evil “Mrs. Perkins” of “the Mother Company,” the sinister adversary of hero Nicholai Hel in “Shibumi,” but still, I do like my tea, at least once in the morning and once in the evening.

duncang

(3,713 posts)
19. Pretty much all I drink anymore.
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 12:42 AM
Tuesday

Is the water method decaf. I have high blood pressure so that was the main reason.

catbyte

(35,894 posts)
21. Oh, heck no. It's either leaded or nothing at all.
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 09:17 AM
Tuesday

De-caf is vile. I'd take another BP pill if I had to.

CTyankee

(65,177 posts)
45. I can't. I had palpitations like crazy the day after Trump won and I called my doc's office.
Wed Dec 11, 2024, 09:05 PM
3 hrs ago

I take Verapamil and I asked if I could take a dose in the morning (I usually take it in the pm at dinnertime). Doc said no, don't do it.

JoseBalow

(5,483 posts)
32. Does it elicit some sort of placebo effect?
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 06:03 PM
Tuesday

I imagine it's mostly former coffee drinkers that go for decaf

JoseBalow

(5,483 posts)
34. I feel more awake just smelling coffee brewing
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 06:08 PM
Tuesday

Probably because I know what's coming once I start drinking it.

rainin

(3,189 posts)
30. Yep! Did it successfully because I piggybacked my cold-turkey withdrawal with a major surgery. I was on so many meds,
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 05:39 PM
Tuesday

I didn't notice the withdrawal symptoms. Worked for me. Found out today that insurance is denying the claim. So, there's that. At least I got off caffeine for my 25K. (And life-saving surgery, too)

fairfaxvadem

(1,258 posts)
35. Made the switch a few years ago...
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 06:39 PM
Tuesday

Started with 1/2 & 1/2, now just straight decaf. The trick is to find some better quality ones. Peet’s dark roast decaf is very good. I’ve backed out of using them since they’re big R contributors, which bums me out. Tim Horton’s isn’t bad, but never StarBurnt. I also like Illy decaf a lot. Not always easy to find. The jitters really started to creep up on me after a certain age, ahem, hence the switch.

irisblue

(34,369 posts)
36. I went half decafe/half caffeinated last yr.
Tue Dec 10, 2024, 06:40 PM
Tuesday

The caffeine hit first thing in the morning hit my anxiety meter way too hard.

I will on occasion during a cup of caffeinated if I need to focus on paperwork.

lark

(24,280 posts)
42. I had a problem that was exacerbated greatly by caffein, had to switch.
Wed Dec 11, 2024, 10:22 AM
14 hrs ago

I hated it, it was so weak and ineffective, I was always tired in the am! Later the problem got worse and I had to have surgery after surgery - but 27 years later, I'm still alive and the pain and stiffness is manageable. After the first major surgery, I got to go back to drinking real coffee. I think t his helped with my recovery as it raised my spirits a lot. Being stubborn and refusing to give in to the excruciating pain also helped a lot, along with "theme songs" and meditation.

milestogo

(18,071 posts)
43. I ONLY drink decaf coffee.
Wed Dec 11, 2024, 06:25 PM
6 hrs ago

A couple of reasons-

1. Chronic insomnia. I went through a process of cutting out caffeine after a certain time of day. Finally I was down to one cup in the morning. That's when I switched to decaf - so its not even a factor.

2. Migraines. Its not the caffeine itself, but the variations in caffeine levels that will give you a headache. For instance, if you drink 5-6 cups in the morning on the weekday, but don't drink any till noon on a Saturday, you're probably going to get a headache. The best thing is to be consistent from day to day.

I don't think decaf tastes any different than regular coffee.

Also, you can buy coffee with half the level of caffeine at the grocery store.

CTyankee

(65,177 posts)
44. I am experimenting with making half decaf and half regular caf. I don't want palpitations from caffeine but frankly I
Wed Dec 11, 2024, 09:02 PM
3 hrs ago

don't think I drink that much coffee in the first place. Usually, it's just 2 cups in the morning.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Has anybody here tried to...