General Discussion

marble falls

(62,426 posts)

22. Hydrox came out first. They both used animal fats in their frosting and cookie. Oreo went to cottonseed oil while ...

Reply to electric_blue68 (Reply #17)

Wed Dec 4, 2024, 03:30 PM

Dec 4

Last edited Wed Dec 4, 2024, 05:55 PM - Edit history (1)

... Hydrox stayed the same. Now we know animal fats are good for you and seed and vegetable oil are worse if they've been hydrogenated, make them more polysaturated than animal fats. Rendered animal fats melt at room temp and vegetable shortening doesn't.

Someone has bought the Hydrox name and is making them, but I haven't seen one or it's labeling.

BIG EDIT: I just realized that the above is how I a drain bramaged individual, may have mixed up fact with who knows what, it is pretty close in a lot of ways of what really happened. I will gladly mea culpa every goof gracefully.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

22 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Happy National Cookie Day!! What's your favorite??? [View all] a kennedy Dec 4 OP

Homemade chocolate chip with toasted pecans or Lunabell Dec 4 #1

Girl Scout Thin Mints stored in the Freezer BOSSHOG Dec 4 #2

Sugar cakes Freddie Dec 4 #3

Pumpkin spice with lemon glaze Beatlelvr Dec 4 #4

Fudge Stripe or 'Nilla Wafers JohnnyRingo Dec 4 #5

All of them!! Diamond_Dog Dec 4 #6

Me too, Diamond_Dog. However... littlemissmartypants Dec 4 #11

My favorite is also Bettie Dec 4 #7

Oatmeal raisin..... marmar Dec 4 #8

The only oatmeal cookie I like is sold at Publix. House of Roberts Dec 4 #10

Not sure, but I know the ones corporate America loves: RedWhiteBlueIsRacist Dec 4 #9

My favorite cookies are ginger snaps. WENSTJDON Dec 4 #12

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip with finely chopped walnuts. ProudMNDemocrat Dec 4 #13

Oatmeal raisin NEOH Dec 4 #14

The original Hydrox cookies. Made Oreos meh. marble falls Dec 4 #15

I remember Hydrox. But don't remember a difference... electric_blue68 Dec 4 #17

Hydrox came out first. They both used animal fats in their frosting and cookie. Oreo went to cottonseed oil while ... marble falls Dec 4 #22

This message was self-deleted by its author Emile Dec 4 #16

Chocolate Chips! Jaques Torres (chocolatier) makes a big Chocolate Chocolate Chip electric_blue68 Dec 4 #18

Snickerdoodles, warm out of the oven. MineralMan Dec 4 #19

Shortbread. GoCubsGo Dec 4 #20

Peanut butter. ... riversedge Dec 4 #21