Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

OKIsItJustMe

(21,016 posts)
31. My point was...
Tue May 28, 2024, 10:48 AM
May 2024

If you want to cut emissions meaningfully by reducing populations, simple means like cutting birthrates won’t work fast enough. We cannot afford to wait generations for it to “kick in.”

As pointed out in the O.P. numerous countries already have Total Fertility Rates “below replacement.” (i.e. less than 2.)

Culling is (if you will) “A Modest Proposal. Or, perhaps a reductio ad absurdum.
.

If we could go back in time and avert the “Post-War Baby Boom” that would be helpful, but (I’m afraid) not sufficient. The “war machines” of World War II burned a heck of a lot of fossil fuel. (i..e. not just the tanks, and jeeps and airplanes, but the factories which made them and the munitions and so forth.)

Even before the 20th century, we were well on the road to ruin.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

The massive imbalance of species... Think. Again. May 2024 #1
Chicken? Egg? OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #5
No chickens, no eggs, just idiocy. Think. Again. May 2024 #7
In past ages, people had lots of children, because many of them would not survive to adulthood OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #10
Reducing excessive population levels would reduce energy needs. Think. Again. May 2024 #13
Are you proposing "culling?" Because we cannot wait for the decades it would take. OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #14
Yes, thanks, in any case, in regards to your OP... Think. Again. May 2024 #15
Don't suppose I was supporting the cause of the "pro-natalists." OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #16
And there it is. Brenda May 2024 #21
I don't get it either... Think. Again. May 2024 #22
Yeah, that and I suppose it could be part fundamentalist religious Brenda May 2024 #23
I've always thought... Think. Again. May 2024 #24
That's true. Brenda May 2024 #25
There's also a fear of "them" outnumbering "us" OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #35
See my post #26. -nt CrispyQ May 2024 #27
My point was... OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #31
We need a new economic system. We're consuming our planet for the profit of a few. CrispyQ May 2024 #26
Oh... There's some validity to the whole issue of an inverted pyramid OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #34
Yeah, I understand the money aspect and we def need a new system. Brenda May 2024 #36
I heard a climate scientist being interviewed recently who said that 50% of all non-pave land is devoted to agriculture. Lonestarblue May 2024 #28
Effective Altruism is a Cult Metaphorical May 2024 #2
Too many humans already for this Dear Rock named Earth. It'll still be here, and thrive, once Traurigkeit May 2024 #3
Don't count on it OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #6
The Earth will thrive, whatever that lives or not lives on surface doesn't really matter. Traurigkeit May 2024 #8
What Lovelock meant was that nothing might live OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #11
Limiting yourself to organics ? Traurigkeit May 2024 #17
Actually, Lovelock did not. OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #19
"If we damage the ecosystem thoroughly enough, it may not be able to recover..." CrispyQ May 2024 #29
I highly recommend John Brunner's 1972 novel, The Sheep Look Up OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #32
I know at least one. SarahD May 2024 #4
He had his Father's money, Elon didn't do anything. Traurigkeit May 2024 #9
Nature? Nurture? OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #12
Give the kids PLENTY of $$$ to nurture them well Traurigkeit May 2024 #18
Money is not a requirement, but (like genetics) it can certainly help OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #20
There's Another Way To Solve the Population Bomb Deep State Witch May 2024 #30
That's not the "population bomb" I'm concerned about OKIsItJustMe May 2024 #33
Immigration is key to US Survival Metaphorical May 2024 #37
Instead of billionaires birthing dozens of nepo-babies... Shipwack May 2024 #38
Hear Hear! Deep State Witch May 2024 #39
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»The Guardian: America's p...»Reply #31