Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

hlthe2b

(107,288 posts)
6. Because the term did not originate within the Hispanic community. I got an earful from Denver to
Sun Sep 3, 2023, 04:56 AM
Sep 2023

Pueblo to Alamosa to Dotsera and Conejos in Colorado-- when I attended outreach forums sponsored by the Denver Post, several local Spanish-language papers, 9-news, academicians from CU and state public health and health outreach officials. The term was universally panned as being thrust upon the community and there was a LOT of resentment. For any that want to suggest it was specific to transphobic bias, that did not appear to be the case in the community, but rather an issue of cultural appropriation and insensitivity by East Coast activists who were perceived to know NOTHING about the very diverse Latino community--nor to particularly care. Much like the Native Americans resented having panels not LED (or at least the majority populated by the community) trying to decide what to do about stereotypical or derogatory high school team names and symbols, this is a highly sensitive issue. Whether or not a term or symbol is well-intentioned, the community MUST accept it.

There were a few activists attending the Hispanic forums who tried to "explain" why the term was needed in the wider community. The backlash was swift and angry with those individuals perceived as patronizing as one could (should?) be imagined. I have well-meaning colleagues working in medicine and health outreach who were quite taken aback by the reactions but definitely learned something important.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Ethnic groups define themselves the way they prefer. brush Sep 2023 #1
Hmm... Mike Nelson Sep 2023 #2
Worse in German Old Crank Sep 2023 #4
I think it's because Spanish relies heavily on "gendered" nouns and adjectives TlalocW Sep 2023 #3
excellent response Skittles Sep 2023 #5
I'm on DuoLingo as well TlalocW Sep 2023 #16
sweet! Skittles Sep 2023 #17
I use Duolingo too. Behind the Aegis Sep 2023 #18
well the next language I thought of was Norwegian Skittles Sep 2023 #19
I have done that too. Behind the Aegis Sep 2023 #20
and Yiddish too Skittles Sep 2023 #21
It's an agreement class. Igel Sep 2023 #22
i speak a little, and i live in a very mexicano hood. mopinko Sep 2023 #9
I'm not sure so much on "hard things" are male, etc. TlalocW Sep 2023 #15
Because the term did not originate within the Hispanic community. I got an earful from Denver to hlthe2b Sep 2023 #6
I knew it roscoeroscoe Sep 2023 #7
What's wrong with the term "Latin"? Is that too associated with stereotypes ... eppur_se_muova Sep 2023 #8
The controversy is over "LatinX" NOT LATIN hlthe2b Sep 2023 #10
Well, DUHH! I'm asking why people don't still use "Latin", like they used to! nt eppur_se_muova Sep 2023 #12
They do. Latino, Latina, Latin are all terms used in lieu of Hispanic and not controversial. hlthe2b Sep 2023 #13
Maybe latinos haven't integrated the term because they aren't as hung up Baitball Blogger Sep 2023 #11
Neo-colonialist claptrap bigmonkey Sep 2023 #14
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Languages and Linguistics»'Latinx': Why do many His...»Reply #6