Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Religion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

Major Nikon

(36,915 posts)
Sat Nov 26, 2022, 08:11 PM Nov 2022

Why did Judas betray Jesus? [View all]

The bible tells us it was for 30 pieces of silver. OK so how much is that? It was a day's pay for a shepherd in the book of Zechariah, but that was 500 years prior. Unless there were some serious deflationary forces going on it seems reasonable it might be as much as that or perhaps less.

The next question is how much was the ministry bringing in? It safe to say these people weren't rolling in cash, but they were evidently making enough to pay the tax man. Given the numerous accounts of them giving sermons to, or healing the rich, it seems reasonable they were pulling in enough funds for general expenses. Whatever the amount was, it was enough for one of them to be treasurer.

Which is the segue into the next point.

Turns out the treasurer was Judas himself. So why not simply run off with the till? Wait till you get a good haul from healing a rich dude's dead penis or something, then take the money and run. Seems like he could have easily cleared more than 30 small.

I realize all of this is made up anyway, but you think they could have made up a better story.

36 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Why did Judas betray Jesus? [View all] Major Nikon Nov 2022 OP
Wow, incredibly inappropriate relayerbob Nov 2022 #1
Inappropriate how exactly? Major Nikon Nov 2022 #7
"I realize all of this is made up anyway, but you think they could have made up a better story." relayerbob Nov 2022 #14
Good question, relayerbob. I seriously wonder about the DUers that feel a need No Vested Interest Nov 2022 #16
I seriously wonder about people who can't stand the thought of having their beliefs challenged Major Nikon Nov 2022 #18
For the record, I;m not a Christian relayerbob Nov 2022 #20
I don't really care what you are or aren't Major Nikon Nov 2022 #23
You're right, I was trying to be nice relayerbob Nov 2022 #25
Bullshit Major Nikon Nov 2022 #26
This isn't a Christian group or any of the others you mentioned Major Nikon Nov 2022 #17
As I pointed, I'm not a Christian and not discomforted relayerbob Nov 2022 #21
I'm pretty sure you are discomforted or you wouldn't be throwing around false allegations Major Nikon Nov 2022 #22
OK, whatever you say relayerbob Nov 2022 #24
Believe it or not you aren't the first to come into this group with your sermons Major Nikon Nov 2022 #27
From the group information: Cuthbert Allgood Nov 2022 #35
I think the silver was a bonus he wasn't counting on. IIRC, he believed he was doing the right thing Gore1FL Nov 2022 #2
The question remains open to interpretation Major Nikon Nov 2022 #8
At that time, tax collectors were called Publicans. multigraincracker Nov 2022 #3
Odd thing is... Effete Snob Nov 2022 #4
Yes. Without Judas, the fable would be too similar to other fables. Marcus IM Nov 2022 #5
since judas did god's bidding judas should be a hero. no judas, no christ nt msongs Nov 2022 #6
Everyone who has ever watched professional wrestling knows there must be a villian Major Nikon Nov 2022 #9
Judas was an early, modern-day, conservative disciple. keithbvadu2 Nov 2022 #10
Nobody had figured out how to make some serious cash out of the deal until Paul came along Major Nikon Nov 2022 #11
On the other hand, Igel Dec 2022 #36
The gospels of Luke and John state that the devil gained entrance to Judas's soul. Frasier Balzov Nov 2022 #12
According to most Christian doctrine is that not true of any sinful act? Major Nikon Nov 2022 #19
... AZSkiffyGeek Nov 2022 #13
Andwritten by Leon Rosselson NoRethugFriends Nov 2022 #15
If you think that Zechariah says it's a day's pay for a shepherd muriel_volestrangler Nov 2022 #28
I think you need to dig a little deeper Major Nikon Nov 2022 #29
Pay or wages, that doesn't make any difference muriel_volestrangler Nov 2022 #30
Wages isn't ambiguous, so yes it most certainly does matter Major Nikon Nov 2022 #31
If it matters, are you going to rewrite your OP which says "a day's pay"? muriel_volestrangler Nov 2022 #32
It's a rather silly exercise which entirely misses the point Major Nikon Nov 2022 #33
As the link says, "would roughly be comparable to four months' (120 days) wages" muriel_volestrangler Nov 2022 #34
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»Why did Judas betray Jesu...»Reply #0