Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(37,985 posts)
25. As usual, the "percent talk" is taken completely out of context. From the full paper, to which I have access:
Wed Mar 25, 2026, 02:41 PM
Yesterday
Notably, triplet yields of up to 200% have been reported in crystals and covalently conjugated dimers, (14−25) and integration of the SF materials onto solar cell devices has been demonstrated to exceed 100% total exciton yield. (26−31) Another promising strategy to exploit the SF process is to convert the energy of separated triplets to photoluminescence (PL), thereby amplifying photons. (32) Triplet sensitization to emissive materials also improves the exciton generation efficiency of near-infrared (NIR) light-emitting diodes, (33) highlighting the broad potential applications of SF in optoelectronic fields.


This is in the first paragraphs of the paper and it refers to exciton yield. It's excitons, not thermodynamic energy recovery.

On inspection, while this claim will produce oodles of wishful thinking, the issue will do absolutely zero to address the environmental, economic and practical limitations of this technology, even if were entirely possible to industrialize this benchtop work.

These are land use, material use, the well known but often ignored reality that energy demand and availability are not linked in technologies dependent on the weather and the time of day, etc.

Solar energy is not sustainable, no matter what chemistry and physics are involved.

Figure 4 in the full paper shows the (very scary) chemistry involved:



These structures are polyaromatic hydrocarbons, powerful carcinogens that are constituents of air pollution and other chemical pollutants associated with petroleum and coal. They are decidedly not synthetically accessible on an industrial scale I would think.

It's a little late for wishful thinking. Solar energy will never be as clean nor as sustainable as nuclear energy, not in this form, not in any form.

It's a fantasy that should be allowed to die a deserved death.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Wonderful news! dlk Yesterday #1
Efficiency Maninacan Yesterday #2
I read where a new record of 30% efficiency was just attained BeneteauBum Yesterday #9
It's definitely a clickbait-y statement LearnedHand Yesterday #3
That appears to be the basis for their claims - improvements in capture of wavelengths not previously handled. erronis Yesterday #4
clickbait-y is an understatement. progressoid Yesterday #12
Haha! Alpeduez21 Yesterday #22
That isn't what they are claiming. Gore1FL Yesterday #29
It's 130% of what they previously thought possible. Gore1FL Yesterday #28
Paper is paywalled. Article above doesn't even give a link. usonian Yesterday #5
Yeah - I tried briefly to find a non-paywalled version of the paper but only found a bunch of references erronis Yesterday #6
Here you go. The PDF was on the JACS site. Can't say I understand any of it, so please verify. erronis Yesterday #8
That's the supporting information. They give that suff away. Thanks for the efforts! usonian Yesterday #10
As usual, the "percent talk" is taken completely out of context. From the full paper, to which I have access: NNadir Yesterday #25
I was relying on you to add your knowledgeable perspective. Thanks. erronis Yesterday #26
And, some energy company will buy it and we will never see or hear of it again. OldBaldy1701E Yesterday #7
Considering that Doturd is using $1 BILLION of our tax dollars to stop an off-shore wind farm... AZ8theist Yesterday #21
Thanks for the post. Solar could be integrated into design of buildings and other things. twodogsbarking Yesterday #11
10% gas Maninacan Yesterday #14
Dream on! The bigger the pickup, the faster they drive. And if you think the high price of gas Wonder Why 20 hrs ago #30
I mean, existing technology could do that quakerboy Yesterday #18
Imagine if this technology is eventually implemented ... aggiesal Yesterday #13
Efficiency Maninacan Yesterday #16
Imagine if the tack and blacksmith industries had done what the fossil fuel industry... Trueblue Texan Yesterday #15
But solar power isn't feasible... Zelda_Orchid Yesterday #17
The % reported was "Quantum Yield" which isn't solar conversion efficiency IbogaProject Yesterday #19
I'm sure Chinese technologists will fully utilize this advance 0rganism Yesterday #20
Excellent! nt Exp Yesterday #23
Why, just the other day a fellow behind the dumpster at my local 7-11 was trying to sell me stock in a molybdenum mine. LudwigPastorius Yesterday #24
If solar panels were as cheap as cardboard and "130% efficient..." hunter Yesterday #27
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Science»Scientists Just Broke the...»Reply #25