Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

melm00se

(5,152 posts)
17. The Constitution discusses "due process"
Tue Apr 8, 2025, 08:02 PM
Apr 2025

But never defines it.

Judge Henry Friendly (yes, that was his real name) wrote an influential article which has been accepted by many as a working definition of due process:

A neutral and unbiased tribunal .
A notice of the government’s intended action and the asserted grounds for it.
The opportunity for the individual to present the reasons why the government should not move forward with the intended action.
The right for the individual to present evidence , including the right to call a witness .
The right for the individual to see the opposing side’s evidence.
The right to cross-examination of the opposition’s witnesses.
A decision based exclusively on the evidence presented.
The opportunity to representation by counsel .
The requirement that the tribunal prepare a record of the evidence presented.
Requirement that the tribunal prepare written findings of fact and reasons for its decision .


Full article here

But that is not in the constitution so, in theory (with this Supreme Court it may be: in fact) the Courts can redefine what is or is not "due process" anywhere along the line.


Recommendations

4 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

the 'constitution' now gives us a prescription for what due process stopdiggin Apr 2025 #1
If there is confusion within the ranks of the stupid presenters, hire one of your MAGA lawyers to explain it. efhmc Apr 2025 #2
US electorate: markodochartaigh Apr 2025 #3
Marx's "Religion is the opium of the people" is now "Sports is the opium of the U.S. Electorate." sop Apr 2025 #27
CBS ignored... consider_this Apr 2025 #4
Still in em..."negotiations" with Trump. Didn't want to rile the fuhrer with tacky protest vids Bengus81 Apr 2025 #29
No one will know what free speech, free press, etc mean either. Irish_Dem Apr 2025 #5
Right before they head over to do a recipe segment. nt moniss Apr 2025 #6
CBS is absolutely correct. We don't know how DOJ will handle this and it's doubtful immigrants will get a fair hearing. Silent Type Apr 2025 #7
Due process has always been a nebulous concept in administrative law hearings Ponietz Apr 2025 #9
Trump will do everything in his power radical noodle Apr 2025 #38
K&R ffr Apr 2025 #8
Sooooooooo much this! ⬆️ Dark n Stormy Knight Apr 2025 #23
As Bull from Night Court said, " I thought due process was how they made Velveeta cheese." spike jones Apr 2025 #10
Perfect example of corporate media. Passages Apr 2025 #11
Well, as we all know, the Constitution means exactly... dchill Apr 2025 #12
I Swear these Republican CABAL women DENVERPOPS Apr 2025 #31
This is why I watch BBC News in the morning. llmart Apr 2025 #13
This is really becoming embarrassing. calimary Apr 2025 #14
The maladministration is probably... WestMichRad Apr 2025 #15
Funny you should post that johnnyfins Apr 2025 #26
Due process: isnt that when somebody is given a summons and an opportunity to defend themselves? SSJVegeta Apr 2025 #16
The Constitution discusses "due process" melm00se Apr 2025 #17
o gosh et tu Apr 2025 #18
Oh my Rebl2 Apr 2025 #19
Edward R. Murrow must be spinning a lot lately too. Dave Bowman Apr 2025 #22
YEP Rebl2 Apr 2025 #32
Yep. The role that the media is playing in "legitimizing" all this can't be understated. Karasu Apr 2025 #20
Agreed, a mockery of journalism. returnee Apr 2025 #25
No, a mockery of journalism would be to pretend to know what exactly will constitute due process in these cases onenote Apr 2025 #42
Did they go to school at some point in their life? Dave Bowman Apr 2025 #21
Did you go to law school? onenote Apr 2025 #41
proves we really have moved into an idiocracy mdbl Apr 2025 #24
Our media is incompetent and/or complicit -misanthroptimist Apr 2025 #28
The administration was quick to bring back Andrew Tate from Romanian prison IronLionZion Apr 2025 #30
IOKIYAR on steroids LymphocyteLover Apr 2025 #34
2016: "Immigrants are rapists!". 2025: literally pressuring allied countries to send rapists to the US IronLionZion Apr 2025 #35
It's purely psychotic and evil LymphocyteLover Apr 2025 #36
will these motherfuckers EVER show outrage for these outrageous acts? LymphocyteLover Apr 2025 #33
This is what capitulation looks like. Media companies, law firms, schools, universities, non-profits next. Evolve Dammit Apr 2025 #37
I'd like for those DUers criticizing CBS to explain what due process requires in the deportation cases onenote Apr 2025 #39
Good post Ponietz Apr 2025 #40
I was just scrolling down through all the nonsense Ms. Toad Apr 2025 #43
200 recs Sympthsical Apr 2025 #44
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Holy Fuck CBS News! "No ...»Reply #17