Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

crimycarny

(1,766 posts)
50. Thank you so much
Fri Mar 21, 2025, 01:57 PM
Mar 21

We have a real problem in our society and even our medical community in the way we think of mental illness. It's the only human disease I know of that is viewed as somehow "fixable" by the very organ that is causing it. Telling someone suffering from depression to somehow magically change their thoughts to more positive, less anxiety, etc. is like telling someone suffering from an asthma attack to 'just breathe'.

It was on DU that I learned about the Stanford SAINT study, now approved by the FDA. (Unfortunately too late for my son.) It's a targeted form of TMS that uses an MRI to get the exact area of the brain to treat. It also uses stronger magnetic pulses and over a shorter period of time. Stanford observed an 80% remission in major depression (MDD), and with no drugs (most in the study were treatment-resistant). Stanford found that in 75% of those suffering MDD, the flow of information between two key areas responsible for the sense of well-being was literally reversed from the brains of those not suffering from MDD. After the TMS treatments that flow was restored back to normal and people felt an immediate relief. One man in his 60s who went through the study said he noticed when he was walking his dog that he felt a sense of contentment and peace, something he had never felt before in his entire life.

That study, to me anyway, proves it's an organic issue going on in the brain, not the "fault" of the person suffering feelings of despondency, self-loathing, and the other horrible symptoms that go along with depression. We need to study depression like we do cancer or any other human disease.

Sorry for the long post. I appreciate you giving me your perspective as someone who suffers from depression.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I think you have a large crowd feeling similarly about our current situation... hlthe2b Mar 20 #1
Thank you BlueKota Mar 21 #30
I lost my son in 2022 crimycarny Mar 20 #2
Hugs and tears Clouds Passing Mar 20 #7
I am so sorry. LoisB Mar 20 #9
I'm so sorry crimycarny Mar 20 #11
Yes, we are never the same. I am so sorry for your loss. Clouds Passing Mar 20 #24
I am so sorry about your son. No greater pain than losing a child. LoisB Mar 20 #8
No greater pain crimycarny Mar 20 #12
You are right. One would have to have experienced it to truly understand. I watched my LoisB Mar 20 #14
This message was self-deleted by its author FullySupportDems Mar 20 #15
I am sorry for your loss. BlueKota Mar 21 #31
Thank you so much crimycarny Mar 21 #50
Working as an ER charge nurse... oldsoldierfadingfast Mar 21 #53
I saw a special Josh Gates did on the Discovery Channel BlueKota Mar 21 #55
I too know where I am going when I leave this place stoned Mar 20 #3
My maternal grandmother died at our home. BlueKota Mar 21 #32
That's beautiful stoned Mar 21 #52
O, my dear Friend.I wish I could wrap my arms around you and tell you that you are loved ((🥰)) Deuxcents Mar 20 #4
Thank you. BlueKota Mar 21 #33
BlueKota, I believe. Clouds Passing Mar 20 #5
I'm so sorry we are living in such awful times. I think staying alive because of love is as good a reason as any LiberalLoner Mar 20 #6
Thank you! BlueKota Mar 21 #34
(((Hugs))). I feel shell shocked lately. It's hard. But I see a strong resistance growing now, too. 💙💙💙 LiberalLoner Mar 21 #37
I think we are all terrified but never think you are powerless and certainly not useless. LoisB Mar 20 #10
Thank you. BlueKota Mar 21 #35
My cousin and I have started ending our phone calls with EverHopeful Mar 20 #13
Thank you. BlueKota Mar 21 #36
I feel the same. FoxNewsSucks Mar 20 #16
The companionship of pets certainly helps. BlueKota Mar 21 #38
I'm your brother BlueKota JMCKUSICK Mar 20 #17
Thank you so much. BlueKota Mar 21 #40
NDEs are more real than this dimension. I had a nonNDE (i took a nap!) and Karadeniz Mar 20 #18
Thank you. BlueKota Mar 21 #41
There are many other worthy animals that would benefit from your love and care JoseBalow Mar 20 #19
I definitely will consider it. BlueKota Mar 21 #39
I have a husband and an 11 year old g-neice I'm guardian of now ms liberty Mar 20 #20
Your niece is lucky to have you. BlueKota Mar 21 #42
We have two dogs that keep us sane RainCaster Mar 20 #21
They are the best medicine BlueKota Mar 21 #43
I have a cat sanctuary. hamsterjill Mar 20 #22
Thank you for being a rescuer, and for staying BlueKota Mar 21 #44
Glad you're here, Bluekota. Permanut Mar 20 #23
Thank you so much. BlueKota Mar 21 #45
I almost died during surgery in late 2022 ... LSparkle Mar 20 #25
Make it stop indeed CountAllVotes Mar 21 #28
I pray every night for it to stop. BlueKota Mar 21 #46
This message was self-deleted by its author 58Sunliner Mar 21 #26
Here for my solitary cat too CountAllVotes Mar 21 #27
It's good the priest came to understand and BlueKota Mar 21 #47
Stay here on the DU and fight, fight, fight!!! applegrove Mar 21 #29
Thank you. I will try my best to fight. BlueKota Mar 21 #48
We are in this together!! applegrove Mar 21 #49
We are here for you too. FM123 Mar 21 #51
Thank you! BlueKota Mar 21 #54
For me, it is my husband. OldBaldy1701E Mar 22 #56
Latest Discussions»Support Forums»Mental Health Support»I'm staying alive for my ...»Reply #50